Hallmark

Matchmaker Mysteries: A Fatal Romance on Hallmark Movies & Mysteries (2020)

The Matchmaker Mysteries: A Fatal Romance is an all original movie on the Hallmark Movies & Mysteries Channel. The movie series stars fan favorites Danica McKellar and Victor Webster. It began in 2019 and had its most recent installment in 2021. Get details on the plot line, the cast list, and see photos from the movie.

What is the Plot Line?

Preparing to moderate a writers’ panel at a romance convention, professional matchmaker
Angie Dove (McKellar) is surprised to run into her old college boyfriend, Ethan Plume (Dan Payne, “The Flash”), who has just taken the reins at his family’s publishing house. But a bigger shock is yet to come, as bestselling writer Beatrice Penn (Anne Marie DeLuise, “Supernatural”) suddenly takes ill onstage – the victim of a fatal dose of poison.

Though bad blood between Ethan and Beatrice makes him the prime suspect, Angie knows he’s incapable of murder. And while she’s promised to cooperate with Detective Kyle Carter’s (Webster) probe, she’s not about to sit idly by when Ethan is charged with the crime. Angie launches her investigation with the same sharp instincts and clever strategies she brings to matchmaking and begins to unravel the mystery behind Beatrice’s death. As she and Kyle grow used to crossing paths, they continue to find common ground, and perhaps something more. However, in her determination to find the real killer, Angie may unwittingly be putting herself at risk.

Matchmaker Mysteries: A Fatal Romance Full Cast

Danica McKellar (Angie Dove)
Victor Webster (Kyle Carter)
Bruce Boxleitner (Nick Colomba)
Cory Lee (Paige)
Dan Payne (Ethan Plume)
Andrew Dunbar (Officer Smith)
Jase Anthony Griffith (Carl)
Laura Gilchrist (Margaret)
Stephen Lobo (Neil)
Benjamin Wilkinson (Ted Penn)
Anne Marie DeLuise (Beatrice Penn)
Iris Quinn (Beth)
Heather-Claire Nortey (Helen Travers)
Brenna O’Brien (Caroline)
Parveen Dosanjh (Nancy Upton)
Garrett Black (Peter)
Drew Weston (Thomas)
Kelly McCabe (Ben)
Dave Santana (Neighbor)
Rebecca Davis (Rebecca)
Anthony F. Ingram (Hotel Desk Clerk)

Watch a Sneak Peek of The Fatal Romance

How Can You Watch It?

The Matchmaker Mysteries: A Fatal Romance is available to stream on Amazon. You can have the option to rent or purchase it.

Stream it Now

Where Was It Filmed?

The Matchmaker Mysteries starring Danica McKellar and Victor Webster was shot in Ottawa, Canada. Fun fact, in case you weren’t aware but this series of three movies was executive produced by Patti Stanger. Patti Stanger, from Bravo’s Millionaire Matchmaker was the brains behind this series!

Are They Making More Matchmaker Mysteries?

In 2022, Danica McKellar told her fans that Hallmark shut down a lot of the mystery series unfortunately and urged fans to contact the network to let them know how they felt. However, more recently Danica McKellar left Hallmark to join the Great American Family Channel, led by former Hallmark CEO, Bill Abbott. So it’s fair to say that Danica wouldn’t be starring in the Matchmaker Mysteries in case they do come back to the Hallmark Channel.

When Did the Movie Premiere?

Matchmaker Mysteries: A Fatal Romance first premiered on the Hallmark Movies & Mysteries Channel on April 25, 2020.

What Movies are Coming Up on Hallmark Channel in 2023?

Alyssa

Alyssa is an editor at TV Movie Vaults. She is passionate about entertainment and pop culture. Always scouring Netflix, Hulu, Lifetime and Hallmark for the newest and best shows.